The actor’s words against family vlogging point to a larger debate
Recently, Fahad Mustafa’s old comments against family vlogging and the overuse of the word ‘content’ resurfaced online and caused an uproar among Tiktokers and YouTubers.
“‘Content’ is the most overrated word in this country. There is no such thing as content. Everyone is selling their families. They haven’t even left graveyards alone. They go to their mother’s grave, and record themselves saying I’m missing my mother, please pray for her. What kind of ‘content’ is this?” Mustafa had said when asked about sharing the screen with digital content creators during a TV appearance. “I can tell a good or a bad story. But I can’t sell my family. I can’t sell myself. If you go on a film or TV shoot, it takes time to do this. They can’t understand that this takes us 8 to 10 hours since they live in a 10-second world.”
While the comment offended the Instagram, TikTok and YouTube content creators especially Rajab Butt, as Ricky Gervais says, “Just because you’re offended doesn’t mean you’re right.”
This back-and-forth has sparked a debate between the traditional media vs digital ‘content’. But it’s not a clash between Mustafa and Butt. The actor didn’t even mention the YouTuber by name. The scope of this is much bigger than a forced, illogical personal feud.
Content overload
What Mustafa spoke about is a worldwide concern of artists in the face of countless challenges faced today. Be it AI coming in as a wrecking ball to destroy authentic human expression, shorter attention spans engineered over the last decade by social media overconsumption or the declining understanding of storytelling and art due to the aforementioned issues, there are already more than enough battles artists today are fighting to preserve their chosen media and forms of expression.
This is not to defend shows like Mustafa’s Jeeto Pakistan, which feed into the same Black Mirror-esque humiliation-in-exchange-of-gifts convention. But Mustafa has created work with a certain artistic integrity in film and TV both, namely Actor in Law and Kabhi Main Kabhi Tum.
However, phone cameras and social media platforms combined today have created an illusion that everyone is an artist, actor, or filmmaker. While the democratisation of the media has had numerous benefits, and this is certainly not an issue of gatekeeping, talking into a camera and showing what you cooked for lunch does not exactly require an abundance of talent or skill.
There are many arguments to be made against family vlogging. The internet is full of stories of disgruntled and traumatized individuals forced by their in-house vlogger, be it a parent or a child, to be documented 24/7 for the sake of views. But the crux of the matter isn’t even that.
It’s the fact that ‘content’ has replaced art, cinema and storytelling.
The issues start with the usage of the word ‘content’ which piles up every artform into one giant automated factory where every creation serves the algorithm and the algorithm, in turn, feeds it back to us.
It disintegrates the distinguishing characters of each art form and strips it of any value. This is why Mustafa’s comments about the word ring true. If everything is content, then there’s no difference between a feature film that takes years to produce and a bag of apples.
This argument doesn’t devalue platforms like YouTube which can be used for a myriad of purposes from education to art and music and everything in between. It criticizes the forced homogeneity of all art forms. And family vlogging is definitely not an art form.
Casting influencers
In recent years, even in Hollywood, we have seen a number of so-called social media influencers turn to film and TV. But none comes to mind when thinking about who has excelled and been recognized for their skills. One can bring up Logan Paul but he has succeeded in WWE and pro-wrestling is a vastly different kind of storytelling than film or TV.
American Dollar Exchange Rate